Is It Time for a PPC Management Quality Score?
October 16, 2014
An email lurched into my inbox.
Have you ever noticed that some emails slip in, some slide in, some explode in, some bounce in… and some… lurch in. If you have an image in your mind of a walker stumbling towards Darryl, then you are approaching my metaphor.
The email went something like this:
“A guy from Google called our client about their AdWords account and he had some concerns that he wanted to talk about. Can you deal with this?”
Let’s stop there.
To a non-tech savvy, SMB, Google is the equivalent of the Greek god, Zeus. I’m not really exaggerating that much. Google carries the flaming thunderbolts of denial, disapproval, and blacklisting. Google has phenomenal, cosmic power (said in the voice of Aladdin’s Genie) and if you get on their bad side, they will blast away at you willy nilly. I’m not arguing here the veracity of this claim, I’m just reporting how many small businesses feel where Google is concerned. They don’t understand how it works, but they fear the reaper (and there’s no Will Ferrell to explore the studio space).
So back to my situation. When Google talks to your client, they jump. When Google calls your existing client and says “I have concerns about your account,” your client freaks out.
As someone who strives to do well in my accounts, spends a lot of time in each, and attempts to stay up to date on the latest changes… I was not happy about this. I gave the rep who had contacted them a call and politely informed him that I didn’t appreciate him contacting my client directly. What if this had been a touchy client, or a new client where the trust level hadn’t quite grown yet? If that was the case, I could have had some serious explaining to do for why Google was calling them directly about “concerns” in their account. Thankfully I’ve had this client for a few years now, and we have a great relationship… though they were still alarmed by the initial contact.
To his credit, the rep was so apologetic I actually kind of felt bad for him. He was in fact, quite alarmed to learn that he had alarmed my client. For Google, this was simply a call to check in on what they thought was a DIY client and they wanted to help him learn about new programs/opportunities/ad types/etc. I let him know that I know this task is part of his job, so I didn’t have a problem with him… but I did have a problem with the system (it seems really odd that there is still no hard system for identifying which agencies are with which clients so the agencies can be contacted first with account suggestions. For instance, I just received an email this morning for a new Adwords account coupon… for my AGENCY email address in which I am already advertising!).
We chatted a while longer (I had recently visited San Francisco for the first time where he lives) and actually hit it off. By the end of the call, this rep was insisting that he contact the client back to make the situation right, even though he had intended no harm. I agreed, and he wrote an email to the client.
This was when I had my epiphany.
His email went something like this: “I was able to discuss your account with Kirk and we covered a few things blah blah blah. BTW, I just want to let you know that I see many AdWords accounts as a rep, and I think you should know that Kirk is doing a great job in your account for a few reasons, blah blah blah.” He wasn’t really making anything up or saying anything ground-breaking, he just called my client’s attention to the fact that he thought I was doing a good job managing the account.
The client response was as positive this time as it had been negative before. Google had just told them that their PPC manager did a great job! Think about it, as a client (unless you have had multiple agencies work on your accounts), you always wonder what you are getting in terms of service. To have Google allay your fears and let you know that you are in a good place? Priceless! For me, the agency, to have a Google rep back me up personally to my client? Priceless! I couldn’t be happier with how the Google rep fixed the situation.
We ALL walked away as happy as this frolicking canine. The client was happy (their PPC pro wasn’t a neanderthal). The PPC pro was happy (I didn’t lose the client, and actually gained trust). Google was happy (we’re still spending money). …and isn’t that the goal?
Is It Time for a PPC Management Quality Score?
What if there was a process for measuring PPC management quality?
What if a client could actually know their in-house or agency was measuring up to certain quality standards?
What if a client seeking out an agency, or seeking out a new professional to bring in-house had some way of identifying the quality of that individual/agency because of previous experiences in which Google could give a measurement of quality?
The immensely positive response from my client in the above scenario alerted me to how strong this sort of search-engine-qualified system could be for clients and PPC Professionals (agency and in-house). Imagine a system like Google Partners, but that is controlled by stringent quality standards so the highest quality agencies or in-house professionals are recognized as such and rewarded as such? Currently, a Google Partner can include a multitude of options ranging from the highest quality, to the terrible.
They already (kind of) do this for e-commerce with their Trusted Stores Program so there must be some way to identify and develop some level of quality with PPC management (yet, without releasing sensitive information of any kind)? Perhaps the “agency quality score” if you will, would be different for e-commerce and lead generation? Could they measure such things as general account structure, active ad A/B testing, conversion rate, CTR, account Quality Score, etc? Sure, there’s a lot of fluctuation in there, but taken all-together we ought to be able to have some level of knowledge as to see if an account is managed by first-timers or pros, right?
This “agency quality score” won’t allow us to measure the all-important and elusive “solid decision making abilities” inherent in the best PPC managers, but it will at least give us a starting place for measuring account quality trends rather than quantity at this point. After all, a consistently high trend in the various measurements of quality likely demonstrates a level of inherent management expertise.
I don’t have all the answers, and I don’t understand all that would go into this. I’m not saying we could do this tomorrow. I’m asking: can we work together as a professional PPC community to help Google move past their interest in increasing funds with quantity and rather begin emphasizing the long-term solution of creating a qualitative culture of trustworthy “expert” agencies and in-house individuals?
This strategy helps engender trust all around and as far as Google’s profit is concerned, the funny thing is that I’ve found a client who trusts me is more willing to trust when I suggest that they increase their budget because they’ve learned that I have their best interest at heart! We all win again.
In conclusion, I believe that it will be in everyone’s best interest if there was some system in place to accurately identify qualities of PPC management, measure them, and then communicate that to the consumer.
If this is done, (1) more businesses can more easily find those agencies/individuals that are actually qualified (no, passing an open book test with a large number of “automated spend increase” questions doesn’t count as qualified),
AND (2) more businesses can rest assured that their current agency/in-house individual is actually qualified, thus, helping to increase their legitimacy and respect with the businesses.
This will make businesses happy (they no longer have to worry about this side of their business because their trust in you continues to increase), us PPC professionals happy (we get to keep our current clients because they trust us more, or it becomes easier for good agencies to get future clients), and Google happy (as demonstrated before, trust in agencies and in-house individuals helps to increase spend at the proper times… also, less damage will be done to the name of PPC when the frustrations should be more accurately applied to poor management).
Thoughts? Terrible idea? Great idea?
Browse By Category
A Buyer Persona Based Approach to Mapping Your Customer Journey
Explore how a persona-based approach is used to enhance customer experience, improve targeting accuracy, and harness behavioral analytics to their business objectives.
The Rise of The No-Click Search Results
Searching for answers and data has never been easier thanks to the help of search engines. Here we’ll discuss the effect that no-click cost is having on ppc, including the growing popularity of voice search.
Becoming Allies With The Sales Team: A Lead Gen Solution
Collaborating with your client’s sales team can provide a treasure trove of insights. Explore how PPC tactics are utilized to help shorten the sales cycle and improve close rates!
A bi-weekly newsletter packed full of resources and strategies that will help make you a better PPC expert.
Hanapin Marketing | The PPC Agency of Experts Behind PPC Hero
The Opportunities Tab: AdWords vs Bing, A Friendly Match-Up
Dive into AdWords and Bing opportunities tabs and see how they compare. This includes accessibility, features, and performance insights.
How to Drive Calls that Actually Convert
Our experts are here to explain how gaining call tracking data can help you close the gap in your customer journey and tailor their experience so they actually convert.
New Facebook Analytics Updates from F8
Learn about journeys and automated insights, new tools announced at Facebook's F8 conference for the Facebook Analytics tool.