Getting Your Ads Right First Time! Case Study: $300 For An Ad?
June 22, 2012
When it comes to writing ads, even the best of us can be guilty of getting a little lazy. Considering how easy it is to swap ads in and out with AdWords Editor, it’s no wonder that we often just throw some ads up and think we’ll switch out the one that isn’t doing so well once we have some data.
However, what if you had an account where you had to pay for every new ad you wrote? What would you do differently? This exact issue occurred recently in one of my accounts. I won’t go into too much detail, but I will say that for legal reasons each set of ads had to be approved at a cost of $300 a time. This meant changing the angle of attack from our normal strategy of regularly testing multiple variables and switching them out as soon as we have enough data. We certainly had to be a little more purposeful about every test and be fairly confident everything we were doing had real value.
The good thing to come out of paying $300 for every ad approval is that it serves as a fairly strong incentive to write some darn good ads! The client wasn’t going to be happy if they thought I was wasting their money on decidedly average ad copy. In order to write the best ads we can, we like to use a feature-benefit matrix to get all our ideas down in one easy place. Not only does this make writing ad copy quicker, but also makes it easier to compare all your potential ads in one go. Take a quick look at this blank matrix below:
In the first column list the top 5 features of your product. Features are the factual statements about what makes your product good: 1000s of new models, free shipping, 30-day free trial etc. Once you’ve listed these try and think of 2-3 benefits for each – these are things that answer the customer’s question “why should I care?” As people with a sales background tell me: You don’t sell features, you sell benefits! Finally, add in some calls to action that you think will work on your particular audience. I’ve filled in one for the fictional wig retailer Jerry’s Wigs:
If you need some help with your CTA column, PPC Hero Kayla Kurtz wrote a great post on writing compelling calls to action earlier this week.
Once you are happy with your list, go through and highlight the key messages you think will have the most impact. See if you can get the opinion of a few other people in your office too, especially if you are paying for each of these ads. Below I’ve highlighted what I consider to be the stronger features/benefits/CTAs for Jerry’s Wigs.
With this in place you have everything you need to write an ad that will touch on all the strongest selling points of your product. Here’s an example I’ve created based on the cells highlighted above. Obviously not everything will fit perfectly but the idea is to get as much as you can in your ad.
The great thing about using ad matrixes is that you can quickly email them back and forth with your client and get them to add rows/columns and to approve all the potential messaging you might want to go with.
So, back to the $300 question – how does this help me? Well, first it means you write the best possible ad first time round. It also gives you a great place to work from if that ad isn’t successful. You can begin eliminating some of the cells from your matrix each time you run a new ad. Eventually, you will have tested most of these features and benefits in just a small number of iterations, rather than over 50 slightly tweaked ads. Make sure to start with two ads that go with different combinations from your F/B matrix in order to get a feel early for which ones have the best overall cost per conversion.
As always, if any of you have come up with any other great ad writing tips, let me know in the comments below.
Browse By Category
Why Online Polls Are Critical To Understanding Your Users
You may believe polls are just distracting or annoying. Challenge yourself today to learn how polls can be critical in understanding your users.
Faster, Easier Mobile Lead Generation with Social Lead Ads
Explore how lead ads work, what effects they can have on mobile conversion rates and next steps for rolling out campaigns across social channels.
A bi-weekly newsletter packed full of resources and strategies that will help make you a better PPC expert.
Hanapin Marketing | The PPC Agency of Experts Behind PPC Hero
What the State of PPC Report Reveals for 2018
This year we had a great turnout of responses and some mind-blowing insights to share with you. Join Hanapin's President Jeff Allen as he walks through what we found in our State of PPC Report for 2017-2018 and where the industry is going.
Bing Ads Content Data To Be Deleted
Bing Ads is Deleting Content Data. What you should know and do before-hand.
What Will 2018 Hold for Social?
In this webinar, join AdStage’s JD Prater and Hanapin’s Steve Burnett as they look into the next year and show you what to look forward to in the social advertising world.