Profit per Impression: A Better Metric for Ad Testing
May 10, 2011
Today we have a guest post from one of our PPC Hero allies! Michael Wiegand is a PPC Guru & Google Analytics Consultant at Portent Interactive, a full-service internet marketing company based in Seattle, WA. In this post, Michael explains why Profit per Impression is the perfect metric for ad testing.
Ad split-testing is one of the core disciplines of PPC. If we don’t test, we can’t improve. And as paid search professionals, we become obsessed with finding the right combination of headline, call-to-action and destination URL to influence better account performance.
But there’s a problem with this discipline, especially from an e-commerce client’s point-of-view: Every impression shown on a poor performing ad is losing them money.
We assuage these fears by educating our clients on sample size, giving them regular updates on the progress of these ad tests. But maybe that isn’t the right approach.
Maybe the better approach is to change our testing metrics.
Calculating Profit per Impression
Striking a balance between Click-through Rate (CTR) and Conversion Rate (CR) optimization can be difficult. But if we knew how much Revenue was being generated every time an ad displayed and balanced that with Cost, that would be far more valuable.
That’s where Profit per Impression (PPI) comes in.
More accurately, PPI derives Profit per Thousand Impressions.
The formula for calculating PPI is:
Here at Portent, we use the ClickEquations bid management platform. Their “Text Ad Zoom” feature calculates PPI automatically:
But you can also calculate it manually using Google Analytics and Excel.
Go to Google Analytics. Drill down to Traffic Sources > AdWords:
Then, drill down to Campaign > Ad Group. Select Ad Content from the main dropdown:
Export this report as CSV for Excel:
In the next column over, create a space for PPI and enter the following formula:
Once you’ve applied that formula, and changed your number format to “Accounting”, you can simply copy and paste it down to the cell(s) below to get PPI for the rest of your ads:
Using Profit per Impression
Now that we’ve arrived at our PPI metric, we can make better decisions with our split-tests.
For example, take these two ads:
Both the Top Ad (A) and the Bottom Ad (B) have run on roughly the same amount of Impressions. A is the clear winner in terms of CTR. But that doesn’t factor in Conversions or CR.
Now look at Conversions and CR for each ad:
B is the clear winner in terms of Conversion and CR. But that doesn’t factor in Cost or Revenue at all. The 6 Conversions on A might’ve brought in far more Revenue than the 8 Conversions on B. Furthermore, the 106 Clicks on A might’ve come at a lower Cost per Click than the 75 Clicks on B.
So let’s bring in PPI:
Low and behold, B takes the cake. It brings in approximately $43 more per thousand impressions shown.
Profit per Impression: The Perfect Metric
Instead of relying on purely CTR, CR, or even Revenue alone to make ad decisions, PPI leverages the only constant in your basic ad split-test – equal impression amounts – and it factors in what your client cares about most: ROI.
Take the guess work out of your ad testing, and use PPI.
How Should You Use Display Advertising?
We hear similar questions from clients on a regular basis. One question we hear often is “How do your other clients use Display Advertising?”
Expanded Text Ads: 7 Million Clicks Say They’re Underperforming
Over the past 6 weeks, we have been lucky enough to experiment with expanded text ads, and frankly, I’m not impressed with their performance.
£300 Off Hero Conf London Ends Tomorrow!
Time is nearly gone to reserve your seat for Hero Conf London, 24-26 October at etc.venues St Paul’s, at a huge discount off the regular conference rate!
A bi-weekly newsletter packed full of resources and strategies that will help make you a better PPC expert.
Hanapin Marketing | The PPC Agency of Experts Behind PPC Hero
Expanded Text Ads Come To Google AdWords Editor
Advertisers have been able to create expanded text ads, but couldn't utilize AdWords Editor. That has now changed with the release of the latest version of AdWords Editor.
Bidding Farewell to Adwords Converted Clicks: Don't Panic
AdWords will soon be saying goodbye to the "Converted Clicks" metric. Learn more about what this means for your account and how to prepare for the transition.
Olympic PPC Ad Strategies
How spectators consume sporting events and a massive expansion in the digital space will prove to shake up who and how advertisers reach their audiences.
Hanapin's PPC Resources Are Now Ungated!
You can now access Hanapin's whitepapers and toolkits without having to fill out a form!
View Ad Creative Through The Eyes Of Your Searchers
Learn to understand that ads do not live in the vacuum of an excel sheet and common practices should be tested.
[New Webinar!] 11 Red Flags To Watch Out For When Working With An Agency
Leveraging Analytics For Remarketing: Picking The Ripest Fruit
Remarketing prevalence is well founded based on competitive returns in both volume and efficiency. With that said, this "low hanging fruit" world isn't always easy to pick.
How To Analyze Time-Of-Day Performance For Luxury Products
The importance of ad schedules varies across industries, services, and products. For e-commerce companies that sell luxury goods, ad schedules are more crucial.
One Week Left to Save 25% at Hero Conf London!
You still have time to join us for Hero Conf London, 24-26 October at etc.venues St Paul's at 25% off the conference price. But time is running out.
4 Common Questions Prospects Ask Me During The Sales Process
There’s always new, hot topics and questions we get asked by prospects to see what our company’s take is, and how we go about implementing from a services perspective. Read what our most common questions are.