Do Mobile Preferred Ads Actually Prefer Mobile?
July 30, 2013
Enhanced Campaigns have been pretty controversial, as I’m sure you’re aware. While some of us here at PPC Hero have experienced some success due to the massive influx of mobile traffic, others are still wrestling with the total loss of device segmentation and traffic control that we previously enjoyed.
Chief among our concerns are business models that focus solely on mobile traffic. We’ve got a few clients with that business model in-house, and Enhanced Campaigns have not been kind to them. While you can maneuver around the clumsy bid modifier system to limit desktop traffic as much as possible (credit goes to Jake for actually pulling it off – he’ll tell you about it soon), it’s still a major oversight in the AdWords system.
One of the potential workarounds to aid with your Device segmentation woes is the Ad Device Preference. Theoretically, this system allows you to define certain ads as Mobile-preferred, displaying different ads to Desktop/Tablet and Mobile users — and allowing you to take advantage of Mobile-specific landing pages.
So, does it actually work?
To find out, we’ll be comparing two different accounts. The first one is a traditional PPC account, focused mainly on desktops with some mobile thrown in. It’s all lead generation, focusing on tightly-controlled geographic targets. It’s been opted in to Enhanced Campaigns for the last couple of months, so performance has had time to stabilize. Mobile bid modifiers range from a meager +3% bump, down to a -80% adjustment.
Here’s how the device performance broke down for the last 30 days compared to the Device preference on the ad:
This is surprisingly segmented. Over the last 30 days, traffic was funneled correctly between Mobile-preferred and All device-preferred ads. The only Mobile performance statistics accrued in the “All” category are by design, coming from Image Ad-based Ad Groups. In this account, every instance of an Ad Group containing both “All” and “Mobile-preferred” ads, traffic was allocated correctly.
Our second account is Mobile-only (or as much as it can be in a post-Enhanced Campaigns world). As such, it makes heavy use of positive mobile bid modifiers and depressed general bids to limit totally irrelevant desktop traffic – which cannot be removed, no matter what. Here’s how the Device statistics performed relative to device preference over the last 30 days:
This is more troubling. Not only do we see evidence of Mobile-preferred ads serving to Desktops and Tablets, “All” ads are still serving to Mobile devices. For businesses with a need for distinct Mobile-specific landing pages, this lack of segmentation is a problem.
In my initial investigation, I wanted to make sure this wasn’t a phenomenon that occurred due to the Enhanced Campaigns forced transition on July 22nd. To that end, here are the same account statistics over just the last five days:
The trend persists even to this day in a very fresh account snapshot. In addition, each Ad Group contains both an “All” and a “Mobile” preferred ad – so this problem isn’t due to oversight, nor is it an account structure issue.
So what accounts for the difference in traffic segmentation in these two accounts? I have a theory.
While these accounts have different aims, and leverage their mobile presence to different ends, they have one main difference that could account for this discrepancy: Ad Rotation.
- Account #1 has properly segmented mobile traffic and makes use of Rotate Indefinitely, Rotate for 90 Days, or Optimize for Clicks.
- Account #2 has poor device segmentation and primarily makes use of “Optimize for conversions” as its Ad Rotation setting.
Examining the data above for Account #2, two things stick out: Impression volume for Mobile-preferred ads is significantly higher than “All” device-preferred ads, but Click and Conversion Volume usually favors “All” device-preferred ads. This is in line with my theory that “Optimize for conversions” ignores device preference. To that end, it will serve whichever ad (and corresponding landing page) it thinks will get you more conversions – regardless of your stated preferences.
This is something we’re going to test going forward, so stay tuned. We’ll have some followup data in the coming months to see if we’re right. In the meantime, if you’ve experienced the same phenomenon in your own accounts, let us know in the comments. Thanks for reading!
How Should You Use Display Advertising?
We hear similar questions from clients on a regular basis. One question we hear often is “How do your other clients use Display Advertising?”
Expanded Text Ads: 7 Million Clicks Say They’re Underperforming
Over the past 6 weeks, we have been lucky enough to experiment with expanded text ads, and frankly, I’m not impressed with their performance.
£300 Off Hero Conf London Ends Tomorrow!
Time is nearly gone to reserve your seat for Hero Conf London, 24-26 October at etc.venues St Paul’s, at a huge discount off the regular conference rate!
A bi-weekly newsletter packed full of resources and strategies that will help make you a better PPC expert.
Hanapin Marketing | The PPC Agency of Experts Behind PPC Hero
Expanded Text Ads Come To Google AdWords Editor
Advertisers have been able to create expanded text ads, but couldn't utilize AdWords Editor. That has now changed with the release of the latest version of AdWords Editor.
Bidding Farewell to Adwords Converted Clicks: Don't Panic
AdWords will soon be saying goodbye to the "Converted Clicks" metric. Learn more about what this means for your account and how to prepare for the transition.
Olympic PPC Ad Strategies
How spectators consume sporting events and a massive expansion in the digital space will prove to shake up who and how advertisers reach their audiences.
Hanapin's PPC Resources Are Now Ungated!
You can now access Hanapin's whitepapers and toolkits without having to fill out a form!
View Ad Creative Through The Eyes Of Your Searchers
Learn to understand that ads do not live in the vacuum of an excel sheet and common practices should be tested.
[New Webinar!] 11 Red Flags To Watch Out For When Working With An Agency
Leveraging Analytics For Remarketing: Picking The Ripest Fruit
Remarketing prevalence is well founded based on competitive returns in both volume and efficiency. With that said, this "low hanging fruit" world isn't always easy to pick.
How To Analyze Time-Of-Day Performance For Luxury Products
The importance of ad schedules varies across industries, services, and products. For e-commerce companies that sell luxury goods, ad schedules are more crucial.
One Week Left to Save 25% at Hero Conf London!
You still have time to join us for Hero Conf London, 24-26 October at etc.venues St Paul's at 25% off the conference price. But time is running out.
4 Common Questions Prospects Ask Me During The Sales Process
There’s always new, hot topics and questions we get asked by prospects to see what our company’s take is, and how we go about implementing from a services perspective. Read what our most common questions are.